Is it just me, or did the GOP coordinate an anti-abortion push based on a doctored video?

Earlier this week, the Center for Medical Progress, a group with affiliations to terrorist sympathizerspublished a doctored video purporting to show Planned Parenthood’s senior director of medical research, Dr. Deborah Nucatola, offering to sell aborted fetus body parts for a profit.

The video actually shows Dr. Nucatola discussing reimbursement for the shipment of tissue samples — a legal, if controversial, practice.

While Republicans across the country said predictably vile things about Planned Parenthood in response, the most curious responses came from House Republicans, who seemed almost too prepared to take a righteous stand against the abominable practices taking place in the name of reproductive health.

That is, of course, because they were too prepared. As Roll Call reported yesterday, at least two Republican lawmakers knew about the video weeks before it was released (the video itself was filmed last year). When one of them, Rep. Tim Murphy, was asked why there was such a long delay between his knowledge of the video and his calls for action, Murphy abruptly ended the interview, telling Roll Call that “This interview didn’t happen,” which isn’t how interviews work.

Congressman Trent Franks told Roll Call that he had seen the video about a month ago, but that he and others wanted to “have as much information as possible so that the authorities could be notified effectively before the media.”

It appears, however, that there was more coordination than information-gathering taking place. Yesterday, POLITICO reported that House Republicans are planning on using the video as political capital to restart a push for abortion restrictions that they had previously had a hard time selling to the American public — defunding Planned Parenthood is high on their list of action items:


Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) and his two top deputies — McCarthy and Majority Whip Steve Scalise (R-La.) — called for investigations almost immediately after the controversial video was made public, including whether [Planned Parenthood] profits off fetal body parts. And within 24 hours, at least two powerful committees had announced probes on the issue.

John Boehner, via Wikimedia Commons

John Boehner, via Wikimedia Commons

McCarthy is already talking about defunding the organization through the appropriations process. And in the Senate, GOP leaders who have been eyeing a vote on legislation banning abortions after 20 weeks of gestation say this will give them momentum to clear the bill later this session.

“I think it really probably enhances the prospects of something like that passing right now,” South Dakota Sen. John Thune, the third-ranking Senate Republican, said Thursday. “I think that’s such an egregious, awful, horrible example out there, which I think just elevates the importance of addressing it. So I think it probably helps the bill.”

GOP lawmakers are making their new, revitalized push knowing full well that the video on which they’re basing their claims is doctored, and that the Planned Parenthood staffer it features does not say what they insist she says. They’ve had at least a month to figure that out, and yet are engaged in a coordinated effort to convince the public otherwise. In other words, they are willfully lying to the American people about the justification for their new round of legislation.

It would be one thing if Republicans engaged in good faith with what Planned Parenthood is actually doing — sending tissue samples from aborted fetuses, with consent of the mother, to biomedical companies for research — and argued that this itself is immoral and should be outlawed. That would be a serious argument, and we would have to engage with it. But by claiming that Planned Parenthood is doing something illegal when they clearly aren’t in an attempt to undermine the organization completely, rather than engaging their opponents on a complex moral issue, they are holding out for total victory by any means necessary.

Bear in mind that abortion services constitute roughly three percent of Planned Parenthood’s activities, and that the other 97 percent of the organization’s services focus on preventing unplanned pregnancies. This means that an estimated 200,000 fewer abortions are performed every year as a direct result of their efforts. If the GOP were serious about reducing the number of abortions performed in the United States every year, they’d be promoting the very expansions of access to reproductive health that they are working so hard to undermine.

Instead, they’d rather trick the American people into believing we can ban our way to morality. I guess we shouldn’t be surprised.

Jon Green graduated from Kenyon College with a B.A. in Political Science and high honors in Political Cognition. He worked as a field organizer for Congressman Tom Perriello in 2010 and a Regional Field Director for President Obama's re-election campaign in 2012. Jon writes on a number of topics, but pays especially close attention to elections, religion and political cognition. Follow him on Twitter at @_Jon_Green, and on Google+. .

Share This Post

13 Responses to “Is it just me, or did the GOP coordinate an anti-abortion push based on a doctored video?”

  1. Demosthenes says:


    Moderator — this is more spam on your website. Please delete.

  2. andy.lotiya says:

    The current market is nothing but debt fueled smoke.”’
    Jobs and job growth. Very funny, that was a good one. You know there are actually people out there who don’t know what is happening and believe that. Good one!!..
    Next Page

  3. Bributly says:

    Super Media Jobs 589$ / day


    http://www.World Media Point Express//Digital//jobs

  4. The_Fixer says:

    I understand that the video was produced by an associate of that little weasel James O’Keefe III.

    So yes, it is an ‘ACORNing’. I also think it’s not going to work – a lot of people hadn’t even heard of ACORN when they became a target, so they didn’t know what it was doing. They know what Planned Parenthood is doing, and in the end, I don’t think this is going to sway people much. When the dust settles, even if PP doesn’t continue to get funding from the Federal Government, it will survive.

    However, there still will be some residue from this attack. I would hope that this residue splatters back on the architects of this plan.

  5. Demosthenes says:

    You are correct, Mr. Green. This was a coordinated hit job. The release of the doctored video and the faux outrage and never to be adopted GOP legislation went in tandem.

  6. ComradeRutherford says:

    They knew this was coming, and they were ready.

    Conservatives only lie, and then investigate everyone that knows they are lying.

  7. rmthunter says:

    And does anyone think any “journalist” is going to ask any of them why they’re starting another witch hunt based on a doctored video?

  8. NMRon says:

    Of course they did. Just like ACORN, Repukes always coordinate their ratfucking. Manufactured outrage plus media fealty.

  9. ComradeRutherford says:

    Conservatives only ever lie.

  10. DoverBill says:

    One would think that there are enough actual issues for conservatives to attack without building straw men to burn.

    Then again, how else could they keep their hate-meters pegged above 98%.

    Watch again as this issues slowly fades in to the sunset as yet another contrived witch-hunt reveals fabricated and baseless charges.

  11. Indigo says:

    It’s an attack, pure and simple. The important part now is to deconstruct the attack, expose it for what it is, and watch for evidence of it in other matters.

  12. BeccaM says:

    Put simply, Planned Parenthood is now in the process of being “ACORNed” — which is to say, they’re being demonized and misrepresented through the deliberate use of doctored video in effort to eradicate the whole group.

    The only reasons this might not work are twofold: First, we’ve seen this particular dance before, with phony video misrepresenting what actually happened. And secondly, unlike ACORN, Planned Parenthood doesn’t get all of its funding from the government.

© 2020 AMERICAblog Media, LLC. All rights reserved. · Entries RSS