Hillary Clinton and the echoes of history

The launch of Hillary Clinton’s campaign opens up a long eighteen months (assuming she eventually secures the Democratic nomination) in which friends and opponents alike will battle to define her. Clinton is likely to change campaign tactics many times, but some things about her are not going to change, and one of them is her religious background.

In an increasingly pluralist America, Clinton represents the mainline Protestant establishment that has been falling from the top of America’s cultural hierarchy.

As a Methodist and a Democrat, she is positioning herself as a standard-bearer for church-going liberals (an oft-overlooked demographic), who are dismayed at the growing influence of right-wing Catholics — such as House Speaker John Boehner, VP candidate Rep. Paul Ryan and Chief Justice John Roberts.

Hillary is thus standing in the shadow of Eisenhower and even older Protestant men. Indeed, we may have to go back to the 18th century to find leaders who had the political appeal, along with the limitations, that she does.

Frederick II of Prussia (born 1712, died 1786) was a ruthless monarch who led his kingdom through two wars against other European powers. He used his Protestant affiliation to great effect in grabbing the Protestant-majority province of Silesia from the Austrian Empire. At the same time, he cultivated an image of the “enlightened absolutist,” willing to take on entrenched interests such as the landed aristocracy so that administration could be modernized. In an age before modern democracy, Frederick used all the techniques of positioning and cunning diplomacy that today’s presidential candidates are expected to have down pat.

Frederick’s adversaries were, for the most part, other monarchs, but his style of rule, with policies including compulsory military service, was considered forceful even by observers of the time. All told, he left a less-than-progressive legacy of authoritarianism in Germany, so much so that his brand of forceful nationalism led him to be embraced as an icon by the Nazis.

Hillary may be able to leave an equally decisive imprint on American history as president, but to get elected she will likely have to incorporate her religious values in her rhetoric, and fashion a somewhat new persona as a leader grounded in Christian faith.  Her Republican opponent is, without a doubt, going to play upon the fears and resentments of conservative Christians; she needs to offer a more forward-looking vision that is also grounded (in fact, better grounded) in Christian scripture. Nostalgia for the 1990s is useless; those who are truly, achingly nostalgic for the days when open homosexuality was taboo in Washington aren’t worth her time.

The quasi-monarchical position of the Clinton family in the U.S. today invites a comparison with hereditary rulers of the past, no matter how populist Hillary’s campaign may appear. I raise the example of Frederick II, an “enlightened champion” of the 18th century to point out that the human desire to see privileged people crusade on behalf of the oppressed (however that slippery term is used) may not have changed that much in 250 years. Hillary Clinton, as Frederick did, must thread the needle of maintaining an image of reliable Protestantism and American tradition while also tapping into the zeitgeist of these post-confessional, techno-utopian times. It is an unenviable task.

Skye Winspur is a 33 year old Wisconsinite who spends his days working with his hands and volunteering for causes he believe in. He writes on civil rights issues; gay history and culture; political campaigns of all kinds; Christian theology; and movies.

Share This Post

15 Responses to “Hillary Clinton and the echoes of history”

  1. Sandra Zander says:

    I was been suffering hard ship from HIV/AIDS since 9yrs now, and i happen to have 2 kids for my husband, and now we cannot proceed to have another kids all because of my disease and now i have do all what a human like i and my husband can do just to get my disease healed, i have went to several places to seek for help not even one person could ever help, until i melt a comment on the daily news paper that was commented by Miss Marilyn about how this powerful traditional doctor help her get cured of the disease (HIV-AIDS) ” my fellow beloved” i firstly taught having a help from a spiritual traditional healer was a wrong idea, but i think of these, will i continue to stress on these disease all day when i have someone to help me save my life?” so i gather all my faiths and put in all interest to contact him through his Email address at [email protected] [email protected] , so after i have mailed him of helping get my disease cured, i respond to me fast as possible that i should not be afraid, that he is a truthful and powerful doctor which i firstly claimed him to be. So after all set has been done, he promise me that i will be healed but on a condition that i provide him some items and obeyed all his oracle said. I did all by accepting his oracle fact and only to see that the following week Dr Okwyzil, mail me on my mail box that my work is successfully done with his powers, i was first shocked and later arise to be the happiest woman on earth after i have concluded my final test on the hospital by my doctor that i am now HIV- Negative. My papers for check are with me and now i am happy and glad for his miraculous help and power.With these i must to everyone who might seek for any help, either for HIV cure or much more to contact him now at these following email now,Email: [email protected] [email protected] ” sir thank you so much for your immediate cure of my disease, i must say for curing my disease, i owe you in return. Thanks and be blessed sir.My name is hope His Email address is:[email protected] . or [email protected] [email protected] you can contact his phone number+2349030387805 or +2349051431151 call,GOD BEBBG YOU SIR

  2. Yvoone Richards says:

    I became HIV-positive in 2013, while I was working in Africa. I’m a health professional, but like most of the 20 million positive women worldwide, I was infected by my long-term regular partner. The challenge for every positive person is to take back control of their lives, in “Living Positively” with the virus. I’d always believed that good health was never maintained only by taking medication. More than ever, HIV reinforced for me that health is not just physical health, but also mental, emotional and spiritual well-being. An important part of the healing process for me is to be active in HIV/AIDS education, support and advocacy. I volunteer in a number of HIV/AIDS organizations, and in particular Positive Women, because the impact of HIV /AIDS on women is very different than from men. As once a positive person, I will forever be grateful to God Almighty and Doctor Osorba to reach me when i thought it is all over, Today am happy with my family living free after the medical doctor have confirmed my HIV status Negative, I have never in my life believed that HIV could be cure by any herbal medicine, I want to make sure that HIV never happens to anyone else. We can’t prevent HIV by punishment, by stigma and discrimination. It’s only through building a safe, supportive and caring environment, that positive people still have hope and they should contact Dr Osorba with this email: [email protected] so they can once again be visible in our community, to educate and advocate, to take better care of ourselves and our families. We’re someone’s daughter, partner, mother, grandmother, sister, aunt. When we get HIV, it impacts on our families too contact him today and leave carefree [email protected] Good luck.

  3. Guest says:

    How Work With yahoo google youtube and americablog…….< i started working online, completing some basic jobs that only requires from you a computer and internet access and I am happier than ever… It's been 6 months since i started this and i got paid so far total of 36,000 bucks… Basicly i profit close to 80 bucks/h and work for 3-4 hrs most of the days.Best part to whole this thing is that you can decide when to work yourself and for how long and you get a paycheck at the end of each week.

    ▬▬▬▬▬☛ http://www.ChoseYourLifeSuccessway


  4. Bill_Perdue says:

    All we have to know about Hillary Clinton is that she’s a right wing religious nut, a warmonger, that she used the race card to go after Obama in 2008 and that shes a union buster.

  5. Houndentenor says:

    If I thought the Clintons were anything like Teddy Roosevelt I’d have already changed my icon to one of those “ready for Hillary logos”.

  6. Indigo says:

    It doesn’t hold up very well, if at all, but in the search for autocrats with liberalising tendencies, Teddy Roosevelt’s just too recent.

  7. mirth says:

    I have to give you props for the Netherlands leap. It’s ballet worthy.

  8. nicho says:

    Hillary’s only moral justification for anything is in the Gospel According to Goldman Sachs. Any appeal to religion is just a political ploy. I’m disgusted by any mention of religion in politics at all. It has no place.

  9. Skye Winspur says:

    It’s a secular country and it isn’t, at least when it comes to where leaders find moral justification for policies. Even in the Netherlands, which is a very secular society, the finance minister is cracking down on banking bonuses, saying “Our Calvinist approach to life is that you have to work hard, to behave, be sensible about your money.” (http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/05/can-bankers-behave/389558/)

  10. nicho says:

    Hillary is whatever the focus groups tell her to be. If they decide they want a nun, she will take the veil tomorrow.

  11. nicho says:

    You may want to read up on Hillary’s connection to The Family before talking about her role as a modern-day Joan of Arc. Beyond that, I find this discussion of how she has to position herself religiously to be unAmerican and pretty offputting. Last I checked, this was still a secular country. I will not vote for anyone who runs on religion. If that means sitting out the election, fine with me.

  12. Houndentenor says:

    Methodist. Always was. They attended Foundry UMC in Dupont back in the 90s (maybe they still do, no idea). Oddly enough the Doles went there too until he decided in 95 that he was running for president and they needed to find a more conservative place of worship. One of my friends sang in the choir there at the time (an excellent choir, btw) and said he saw them there every Sunday (together or alone) unless one or both were out of town.

  13. Houndentenor says:

    Frederick II? I’m a frequent Clinton critic/skeptic, but even I think that’s an ridiculous stretch.

  14. Indigo says:

    Hilllary the WASP? I can see it but I didn’t know she was Methodist, I thought she was actually Presbylutherian like the Simpsons. Regardless, the new ‘Grandma’ meme looks good on her. Shades of ‘Mom’ on Futurama. OMG! She’s an assembly of cartoon women!

  15. 2karmanot says:

    Ready?—-5,4,3,2,1: the Hitlery meme begins.

© 2021 AMERICAblog Media, LLC. All rights reserved. · Entries RSS