GOP activist Crowder accused of provoking MI union members, selectively editing video

Ruh roh. Conservative activist Steven Crowder is facing a bit of heat from both the conservative media and the mainstream media, after his supposed “assault” by union members in Michigan.

It seems video of Crowder being punched by a Michigan union member “somehow” left out a key snippet – that was exposed by Fox’s Sean Hannity, of all people (mistakenly, of course – we wouldn’t to accuse Hannity of intentionally practicing journalism) – that shows the union member getting up off the ground and then punching Crowder, suggesting that perhaps something happened to knock the union member to the ground and provoke him to strike back.

This was exposed, as I said, by Hannity, by accident in a segment that was meant to laud Crowder. The NYT has the story, but in a nutshell, Chris Savage of Eclectablog (who I met the other day for the first time at RootsCamp) first noticed that Crowder’s video seemed to be selectively edited.

Crowder fought back against the charges and claimed the full video was released on Hannity’s show, so people could check it and see that he didn’t selectively edit it. Well, the NYT concluded, the Hannity video proved Crowder wrong. A key part was left out. Chris Savage was right.

Yeah, who could have ever imagined a conservative video-gotcha activist would selectively edit a video to make it appear something happened in a way that wasn’t completely true, when that’s what most of the top conservative video-gotcha activists has been doing for years.

Crowder’s credibility took a second blow when a fellow conservative video journalist, who used to work with the Daily Caller, criticized Crowder, seemingly insinuating that he may have helped provoke the violent confrontation.

From Rosie Gray at BuzzFeed:

Video of conservative activist Steven Crowder’s tussle with a union member in Michigan this week, which led to the Fox News contributor being punched, and knocked to the ground, has gone viral in the conservative media — but it’s being panned by other career mischief-makers in the media who believe Crowder fumbled his performance.

Michelle Fields, a former video journalist for The Daily Caller who used to regularly cover Occupy Wall Street, said Crowder appeared to violate one of the first rules of this kind of stunt reporting: Don’t taunt the protesters.

“Going to liberal rallies and confronting people is a delicate situation,” Fields said. “It’s important not to taunt because you’re just putting yourself at risk.”

First, here’s the video that Crowder released, which does not show the union guy picking himself off the ground before hitting Crowder:

Now, here’s the Hannity video where you can see, clearly, that something happened first to the union guy that appears to have provoked his violent reaction:

And here’s Jon Stewart with more the background of what’s going on in Michigan with the “right to work” issue that’s leading to these protests:


Follow me on Twitter: @aravosis | @americablog | @americabloggay | Facebook | Google+. John Aravosis is the editor of AMERICAblog, which he founded in 2004. He has a joint law degree (JD) and masters in Foreign Service from Georgetown (1989); and worked in the US Senate, World Bank, Children's Defense Fund, and as a stringer for the Economist. Frequent TV pundit: O'Reilly Factor, Hardball, World News Tonight, Nightline & Reliable Sources. Bio, .

Share This Post

  • cole3244

    hannity is such a tool that he tries to accuse when the video implies just the opposite, of course when your viewers are fox noise morons they will believe anything but their lying eyes.

  • Sweetie

    Witness talks about Americans for Prosperity inside job (tent collapse and such).

    http://seananthonyblog.wordpress.com/2012/12/12/steven-crowder-gets-slugged-whines-about-it-on-fox-news/

  • Sweetie

    What a parasite.

  • caphillprof

    This is reprehensible. There should be a way to shut down Stephen Crowder and James O’Keefe and others of their ilk.

  • ckg1

    John: It’s not that Crowder “seemingly insinuated” that he started it. Crowder ADMITTED this, on tape, in an interview he did with Canada’s imitation of Fox, Sun News.

  • Alanzo Hern

    How can you tell when a Fox political reporter is lying?

    His lips are moving.

  • Its True

    One of the AFP clowns actually was armed at the protest. This tough ass old dude said he would kick their ass too, gun or not.

    And conservatives think they are the tough ones.

  • Sweetie

    More like “free speech zones”.

  • goulo

    In the blog post, I only see the first video (” the video that Crowder released”)

    The last 2 links seem to be missing (“Now, here’s the Hannity video where you can see, clearly, that
    something happened first to the union guy that appears to have provoked
    his violent reaction:

    And here’s more on the background of what’s going on in Michigan with
    the “right to work” issue that’s leading to these protests:”)

  • Sally

    Oh that was precious. “You do not go to libera rallies and taunt.” What? No one goes to ‘conservative rallies’ period, because they come with loaded guns, remember?

© 2014 AMERICAblog News. All rights reserved. · Entries RSS